| Year | Player | Pos | Class | Division | 
		
			| 2024 | Finnigsmier, Colin Justice, Creed
 | DB OL
 | So. 5th
 |  | 
		
			| 2023 | Justice, Creed Sarich, Jonathan
 Walker, Jonathan
 | OL DL
 P
 | Sr. Sr.
 Fy.
 |  | 
		
			| 2022 | Ballman, Kendall Rau, Ean
 | DB LB
 | Sr. 5th
 |  | 
		
			| 2021 | Brumbaugh, Davis Justice, Creed
 Rau, Ean
 | ST OL
 LB
 | Jr. So.
 Sr.
 |  | 
		
			| 2019 | Curtis, Amari Gibbons, Charlie
 McKnight, Corey
 Rau, Ean
 Rau, Garrett
 Shutter, Kobe
 | DL OL
 OL
 LB
 DB
 TE
 | Fr. So.
 Jr.
 So.
 Sr.
 Sr.
 | South Division South Division
 South Division
 South Division
 South Division
 South Division
 | 
		
			| 2018 | Anderson, Jordan Economos, Evan
 Lee, Hunter
 McKnight, Corey
 Rau, Garrett
 | DL DB
 WR
 OL
 DB
 | Sr. Sr.
 So.
 So.
 Jr.
 | South Division South Division
 South Division
 South Division
 South Division
 | 
		
			| 2017 | Economos, Evan McCaffrey, Matt
 Paul, Jacob
 | DB QB
 DL
 | Jr. Sr.
 Sr.
 | South Division South Division
 South Division
 | 
		
			| 2016 | Donahue, Jack James, Dalton
 | OL RS
 | Sr. So.
 | South Division South Division
 | 
		
			| 2015 | Coffey, Sam Donahue, Jack
 McGlauchlen, Brennan
 Paul, Jake
 | DB OL
 OL
 DL
 | Sr. Jr.
 Sr.
 Jr.
 | South Division South Division
 South Division
 South Division
 | 
		
			| 2014 | Benton, Cahz Compton, Rob
 Emini, Illir
 Finley, Austin
 Gabel, Brock
 Schulz, Ryan
 White, Terry
 | DB OL
 WR
 DL
 ST
 TE
 RB
 | Sr. Sr.
 Jr.
 Sr.
 So.
 Sr.
 Fy.
 | South Division South Division
 South Division
 South Division
 South Division
 South Division
 South Division
 | 
		
			| 2013 | Tallman, Phil | RS | Sr. |  | 
		
			| 2012 | Moon, Neal | TE | Jr. |  | 
		
			| 2011 | Lillibridge, Doug Willits, Jordan
 | P OL
 | Jr. So.
 |  | 
		
			| 2009 | Kizior, Dan | RS | Jr. |  | 
		
			| 2007 | Hill, Tyler Rutledge, Jaran
 Willits, Aaron
 | LB DL
 RB
 | Sr. Sr.
 Sr.
 |  | 
		
			| 2006 | Becque, Brad Hill, Tyler
 | OL LB
 | So. Jr.
 |  | 
		
			| 2005 | Davis, Jim Magruder, Neil
 Megli, Kevin
 Sherman, Luke
 | OL DB
 RB
 DL
 | Sr. Sr.
 Jr.
 Sr.
 |  | 
		
			| 2004 | Abbott, Ben Lennox, Zach
 Magruder, Neil
 | TE DL
 DS
 | So. Jr.
 Jr.
 |  | 
		
			| 2003 | Abbott, Jesse Bonstead, Cory
 | WR OL
 | Sr. Sr.
 |  | 
		
			| 2002 | Abbott, Jesse Bonstead, Cory
 Hawf, Stephen
 Kopf, Seth
 Singleton, Vince
 | WR OL
 LB
 DB
 RB
 | Jr. Jr.
 Sr.
 Jr.
 Sr.
 |  | 
		
			| 2001 | Handcock, Matt Neagle, Tom
 Singleton, Vince
 | OL WR
 RB
 | Sr. So.
 Jr.
 |  | 
		
			| 2000 | Handcock, Matt Keen, Kevin
 Wherley, Adam
 | OL DB
 WR
 | Jr. So.
 Sr.
 |  | 
		
			| 1999 | Buckley, Adam Cannady, Ryan
 | QB LB
 | Jr. Sr.
 |  | 
		
			| 1998 | Roake, Steve Sepich, Marc
 Warwick, Chris
 Wilson, Nate
 | DL DB
 DL
 LB
 | Jr. Sr.
 Sr.
 Sr.
 |  | 
		
			| 1997 | Parson, Matt Schoenwetter, Dave
 Stuffelbean, Ryan
 Tracy, C.J.
 Warwick, Chris
 Wozniak, John
 | LB QB
 RB
 DL
 K
 WR
 | Sr. Sr.
 Sr.
 Sr.
 Jr.
 Jr.
 | South Division South Division
 South Division
 South Division
 South Division
 South Division
 | 
		
			| 1996 | Butcher, Colby Hayden, Matt
 Irby, Jeff
 Rachel, Steve
 | DS RB
 DB
 OL
 | Sr. Jr.
 Sr.
 Sr.
 | South Division South Division
 South Division
 South Division
 | 
		
			| 1995 | Finke, Joey Rachel, Steve
 Schoenwetter, Dave
 | DT OL
 QB
 | Sr. Jr.
 So.
 | South Division South Division
 South Division
 | 
		
			| 1994 | Cornthwaite, Mike Pitcher, Matt
 Sory, Mike
 Tylka, C.J.
 | TE OL
 DE
 WR
 | Sr. Jr.
 Sr.
 So.
 | South Division South Division
 South Division
 South Division
 | 
		
			| 1993 | Cornthwaite, Mike Keiser, Grant
 McCavitt, Mike
 Metzka, Joe
 Pitcher, Matt
 | DS DB
 LB
 P
 OL
 | Jr. Sr.
 Sr.
 So.
 So.
 | South Division South Division
 South Division
 South Division
 South Division
 | 
		
			| 1992 | Raya, Paul Rodgers, Tracy
 Wenk, Andy
 | OL LB
 WR
 | So. Sr.
 Jr.
 | South Division South Division
 South Division
 | 
		
			| 1981 | Durocher, John Wise, Jim
 | WR QB
 | Sr. Sr.
 |  | 
		
			| 1980 | Hahn, Mark Harada, Paul
 Peterson, Pete
 | OL P
 DB
 | Sr. So.
 Jr.
 |  | 
		
			| 1975 | Brown, Gary | K | Sr. |  | 
		
			| 1974 | Baumgartner, Steve Scheid, Jay
 | DL RB
 | So. Sr.
 |  | 
		
			| 1973 | Scheid, Jay Truttmann, Rick
 Walton, Steve
 | RB RB
 DT
 | Jr. So.
 Sr.
 |  | 
		
			| 1972 | Miler, Pat Truttmann, Rick
 Wright, Mike
 | TE RB
 OT
 | Sr. Fy.
 So.
 |  | 
		
			| 1971 | Mclntosh, Mark Radosky, Dennis
 | WR G
 | Sr. So.
 |  | 
		
			| 1970 | Abbott, Monty Bolier, Bob
 | DE RB
 | Jr. So.
 |  | 
		
			| 1969 | Baumeister, Jerry Norman, Ralph
 | S RB
 | Jr. Jr.
 |  | 
		
			| 1967 | Foss, Bill | DB | Sr. |  | 
		
			| 1966 | Politi, Pete | LB | Jr. |  | 
		
			| 1964 | Botthoff, Duke Heck, Jim
 | DB DE
 | Sr. So.
 |  | 
		
			| 1963 | Botthoff, Duke | DB | Jr. |  | 
		
			| 1962 | Dallman, Glen Graening, Jay
 Graening, Jay
 | OG E
 DB
 | So. Sr.
 Sr.
 |  | 
		
			| 1961 | Graening, Jay | DB | Jr. |  | 
		
			| 1960 | Boyd, Bill | B | Sr. |  | 
		
			| 1956 | Maller, Dave Olson, George
 | QB E
 | So. Sr.
 |  | 
		
			| 1955 | Stanicek, Frank | HB | Jr. |  | 
		
			| 1954 | Stalker, Paul | E | Sr. |  | 
		
			| 1952 | Fairman, Pat | FB | Sr. |  | 
		
			| 1951 | Angeloff, Phil McFarland, Bob
 Ogden, Bill
 Pacey, Jack
 | RB E
 DB
 DT
 | Jr. So.
 Sr.
 Jr.
 |  | 
		
			| 1950 | Lundeen, Ken Verner, Walt
 | E E
 | Sr. Sr.
 |  | 
		
			| 1949 | Bahorich, George | G | Sr. |  | 
		
			| 1948 | Carstens, Al | T | Jr. |  | 
		
			| 1947 | Hazen, James | T | Jr. |  | 
		
			| 1946 | Robinson, Bob | HB | Sr. |  | 
		
			| 1942 | Frazer, William Howes, Tom
 | E C
 | Jr. Sr.
 |  | 
		
			| 1940 | Radosevich, Ezidor | G | Sr. |  | 
		
			| 1939 | Petrick, Russell Radosevich, Ezidor
 | E G
 | Jr. Jr.
 |  | 
		
			| 1938 | Christiansen, Al Kleinhans, Al
 | HB G
 | Jr. Sr.
 |  |